Kurt Nelson 0:08 Welcome to Behavioral Grooves. I'm Kurt Nelson, and I'm here with my co-host of nine years, mr. Tim Houlihan. Tim Houlihan 0:14 Wow! Thanks, Kurt. It's it's exciting, right? It's great to be here. And I want you to picture this, Kurt. You work, yeah. Just imagine you work in a contact center for a big retailer. Okay, you take calls. For most of your calls, they're pretty simple. Where's my package? Can can you help me change my address? You fix it. You say, "Hey, I got this taken care of." The customer says thanks, and then you move on to the next call. Okay. Kurt Nelson 0:40 Yeah. All right. That honestly, right now, with all the work that I'm kind of doing and all the crazy stress and everything, that that actually sounds kind of pleasant. You know, straightforward. I'm helping people out. Richard Chataway 0:53 Yeah. Kurt Nelson 0:53 Lower stress. You know, it's like, hey, change address. I can do that for you. Here you go. Predictable, right? Tim Houlihan 1:00 I'm not sure every call goes like that, but for the most part, I'd be okay with that. Fair enough. Okay, but hang with me for just a second. Your company decides to bring in an AI agent to help all those easy calls, like where's my package? Can you help me change my address? So now the calls that reach you end up sounding like this. Hey, your delivery driver just drove over my prize-winning roses. He says he's not even sorry. So, what you gonna do about Richard Chataway 1:31 it? Okay, that was a bad Tim Houlihan 1:34 James Cagney. Is that is Kurt Nelson 1:35 that? I was wondering whose who whose accent, what what kind of accent? But I I get it. That would be crazy, and and and we're getting those because AI is taking away. Hey, I need to change my address here. All right, right. So we don't get any of those. We just get the we just get this crazy, you know, prize winning roses guy all day, huh? But this is the problem. Then your whole day, every day, basically becomes this this nightmare of the worst calls. And and this story comes from Tim Houlihan 2:09 our guest Richard Chadaway, and we're going to talk to him about some of the human consequences of implementing AI. Kurt Nelson 2:17 Okay, just before we, you know, that doesn't sound like fun to me, so I would you know that I'll take the stress that I have right now. That James Cagney talking about his prize winning you know roses on that. So all right, before we get into that though, we just got a little bit of bragging news that we want to talk about? We are proud to announce that Behavioral Grooves was selected by Feedspots panel as one of the top 52 social science podcasts on the web, along with shows like Hidden Brain and Human Centered and Opinion Science. We are so grateful, and by the way, we're not 50. We're not number 52. Just well, and this is 52 because it's one per week. So every, it's like you can listen to a new podcast once every every week. So that we Tim Houlihan 3:08 are grateful, and the credit goes to you, really, our grooves, and to the guests who have shared their cool ideas with us. So check out our link to FeedSpot if you're interested in getting into their content and all their shows, you can check it out in the show notes. Kurt Nelson 3:24 All right, okay, back to Richard. So, Richard is the author of the Behavior Business with a foreword by our friend Rory Sutherland, and it's a book about how some of the world's best-known companies have used behavioral science, sometimes on purpose, sometimes by accident, in order to win, to to be better, right? And he interviewed 25 experts for it, and he's broken the book out into highly digestible lessons. Tim Houlihan 3:52 Yeah. So Richard has spent his career doing this sort of work, from advertising at Ogilvy to leading teams that apply behavioral science and contact centers and customer experience. He's a practitioner, which we love, right? And that means that he's really got great stories from the field, which makes the book super easy to read and super wonderful to read, and our conversation all the richer. Kurt Nelson 4:14 And Tim, you found this super exciting that he's a St. Louis Cardinals fan. Can you believe that? Yeah, Tim Houlihan 4:20 my my hometown team. Yes, Kurt Nelson 4:22 so he tells the story about how he wandered into the old Busch Stadium back way back in 2003, and his fate as a fan. Well, it was sealed, so you know that was pretty cool. And we should also take a little time to just shout out Matt Johnson, our friend Matt Johnson, who introduced us to Richard and and made this episode happen. Tim Houlihan 4:46 Absolutely, thanks very much, Matt. Okay, so in our conversation with Richard, we cover a lot of ground in this discussion. Just for instance, we talk about why Homer Simpson, not Homo economicus, runs. Most business decisions: How one of the closing lines for the bank's phone conversations with customers moved 14% of customers to digital channels, and how KFC stole sold more fries by limiting them to four per customer. How about that? And we have to tell you that we have had some very serious connectivity issues on this call with Richard, and it led to some serious audio troubles, which led to a lot of editing. So we've given it our best effort to piece together and make it sound good for you. We hope that it works. Kurt Nelson 5:36 True, and and we are extremely extremely grateful to have such great audio partners in Orange Wall to help us with this editing and the sound design, and so kudos to them because that is a big, you know, big big lift that we had to do here. Okay, here's another key thing that we think that you will hear or should take away from this episode, we talk about a study Richard shared about honesty, how shoppers regularly return clothes that they don't like, but with this one case, they could only get their shipping feedback by claiming that the items were faulty. Now, they weren't necessarily always faulty, right? But when you deal with a human agent, when people return these, 12% of the customers lied so they could get their shipping fees back. But when they dealt with an AI agent Tim, guess how many people lied? Well, you don't have to guess. You knew 62% lied. Tim Houlihan 6:49 Right, same clothes. It's the same few dollars. Five times as many fibs, just because there was no human on the other end. And Richard's point about this is simple: your customers are still human. Your employees are still human, right? And when you take the human out of the conversation, you don't take the human nature out of it. Ooh, that's a lovely little twist there. Okay. Also, stick around for the music discussion too. Richard is a big fan; he's a huge music fan, and his desert island picks are Blur and a band that not too many people know of, but its name does think make you think of like teddy bears and or a furry convention. I'm just going to kind of leave it vague there, but you'll need to find out exactly who that band is. And if you've heard of that band, give us a shout and tell us what your favorite Blur and this other band songs are. Well, Kurt Nelson 7:55 Tim, you had never heard of Blur or this band. No, I had heard of Blur. Tim Houlihan 7:59 You Kurt Nelson 8:00 and you were you're a big Blur fan. I do. Song number two, fantastic song. There you go. All right. Now sit back with a nice warm pour of Richard's. Test it before you trust it. Take on behavioral science and enjoy our conversation with Richard Chadway. Tim Houlihan 8:30 Richard Chaddaway, welcome to Behavioral Grooves. Richard Chataway 8:33 Thank you. Thanks for great to be here. It is Tim Houlihan 8:36 a delight to have you here. And just a quick shout out to our friend Mac Johnson for connecting us, that's really kind of lovely to have that going on. So, a quick shout out to him. Okay, we're gonna start with our famous speed round. Would you prefer to have dinner with your favorite athlete or favorite musician? Richard Chataway 8:54 Oh, that's a really tough question. Yeah, I I have a feeling, musician. It might be a St. Louis Tim Houlihan 9:02 Cardinal, or it might be. Oh well, Richard Chataway 9:05 yeah, or or well, my those of you watching the video could see a football in soccer shirt behind me for my team at Ipswich Town, who are, let's just say, have been on an up and down progress over the last, the last, well, the time, my lifetime certainly, but there are on a bit of an upward trajectory at the moment, which is good. But um, and and so my favorite sports person would probably be an Ishpel player, and and when I think about it, I think I think the stories from my favorite musicians will be better and probably make them better company over dinner. I think, if you know what I mean. Um, if I think through some of my favorite musicians, which maybe we'll get onto later, I think they will have more interesting and more varied stories potentially. Sex, drugs, and rock Tim Houlihan 9:49 and roll. Yeah, yeah, indeed, Richard Chataway 9:51 indeed, yes. Kurt Nelson 9:53 I like the varied part because I do think that's probably true, right? Where you could talk a long time and have really great conversations. With you know your favorite sports player, and it might vary a little bit, but with a musician, it's going to be it could be, and again, that's probably we're probably stereotyping. I think so. I think we're Tim Houlihan 10:13 stereotyping, Kurt Nelson 10:14 but well, they Richard Chataway 10:15 spend so much time training, don't they? I guess that it's you know that they're going to they're not going to get to see the world, perhaps as much as a musician will, or you know, obviously, musicians, depending on the musician, they might have an innate talent, in which case they've been able to, you know, they haven't maybe haven't had to practice quite as much. I don't know. Just like Kurt Nelson 10:35 Tim, there you go. Richard Chataway 10:36 Absolutely. All right, we're gonna go. I'm gonna I'm gonna move this Kurt Nelson 10:40 forward onto our second question before Tim tries to respond in some snarky way. Richard, are you a coffee drinker or a tea drinker? Richard Chataway 10:50 Well, both actually. Okay, I I am a fan of both. Being British tea is kind of something we're born with, and we we have to is is innate part of the culture. If you don't drink tea, then people view you very suspiciously in the UK. Fair enough. But I do. But I do like my coffee, and I used to live in in Australia as well, where the coffee culture is absolutely huge. So, you know, suppose I remember one of your previous podcast guests was talking about whether Australia or New Zealand invented the flat white, and that's a big, you know, big, you know, bone of contention between the two countries, but you know, but yeah, I got very into my coffee when I was living in Australia, so that's and that stayed with me ever since. So, so I do, I do both. I'm yeah, which I know is is a bit of a fancy. We've had we've Kurt Nelson 11:36 actually, I mean, out of all we ask that question, as you know, it's probably the most asked question that we've ever asked on Behavioral Grooves, and we get all across the board. Some people don't drink either. Some drink one or the other, obviously. And then there's the the both and different pieces. People from England, though, seem to have to have moved out of England to be a coffee drinker and live somewhere else for a period of their lives. If they have never lived outside of England, it's always just tea. Is that would you? Is that? Yeah, I think that's a really Richard Chataway 12:10 interesting. I think that's a fair assumption. Yeah, that is a really good insight. I think because for a long time it was very difficult to get good coffee in England. To be honest, yeah. And when you there's a there's a brilliant book. I'm trying to remember what it's called about the history of coffee and about the kind of coffee house culture that grew up. If you go to London, there's there's a number of places that date back hundreds of years, which were the coffee houses, which were where trading first started in the city of London, where people were trading, you know, imported goods and and the coffee house culture that built around that. So it's kind of weird that coffee kind of fell out of fashion and favor in England for so long. After that, when when it was quite pioneering in at that stage, but but yeah, I think there is something in that. You know, if you've got if you've experienced the coffee culture that exists in other countries like like the US, for example, then then you suddenly get immersed in that, and perhaps it becomes a bit more of a of a thing. But environment matters. Tim Houlihan 13:07 Yeah, it does. Context Richard Chataway 13:09 context is critical, as we know. Yeah, absolutely, Tim Houlihan 13:12 absolutely. Okay, third Peter on question, Richard: True or false? Is it possible that you can successfully operate a business based entirely on behavioral science principles. Richard Chataway 13:24 Ooh, well, entire yes. Well, I would say yes, and and I guess that's kind of good. Well, yeah, we'd we'd all be in trouble otherwise, I guess. But but it's yeah, absolutely. There are, and I think you know one of the things that I I outlined in my book, the behavior business, is that there are a number of success stories, particularly with some of the largest 21st century businesses, about how they've built their business and how they've created unique experiences that have set them apart and driven their success, based around behavioral science principles. Now, some of that is hindsight. You know that wasn't necessarily they weren't necessarily designing that way, and they weren't designing for behavior. But they found some of those things by accident in some cases, and and that. But it has driven the success of those businesses, and has been fundamental to to that success. So and that's you know so there's lots we can learn from that and there's lots of businesses that that are you know as I put it in the book that are flying in the face of what we know about behavior you know every business is in the business of behavior is the is the hypothesis of my book you know if you're in business you're in the business behavior you want people to be delivering products and services in the most effective way possible. The people within your business, your employees, and you want your customers to be buying those products and services. And those are behaviors. And therefore, the understanding of behavior and how and why people behave as they do is critical to your success and influencing those behaviors in the right way. And therefore, that's the. The mental value of behavioral science. Kurt Nelson 15:02 Okay, I love that, and we're going to dig into that much deeper as we tend to talk to you further. But I have the fourth, you know, speed round question, and so for people who have listened to the show a long time, you know, we we make many more questions than we actually ever ask, so I think we have like 15 speed round questions that we can pull from here, and of course two of them are usually the first two that we never change. So we have 13 extra questions that we could ask, and I'm being torn here. I have two questions, so I might I might do a twofer here. Are you Tim Houlihan 15:41 going to try and do a pull a two parter here? Kurt Nelson 15:44 I'm going to try to do two parter, even though they're two very different questions. I'm gonna, I'm gonna, I'm gonna try this. I'll try and be more succinct than my previous one, Richard. You're gonna get this. Here you go. Okay. All right. So I'm gonna start with four A question four A here on our speed round, Homo economicus or Homer Simpson, which one runs most of the business decisions that we make? Richard Chataway 16:09 Well, I would say Homer Simpson, and and you know if you want evidence for this, there's a study that was conducted by by Google with with a business called CB now Gartner, where they looked at the decision making of 3000 decision makers across multiple sectors and industries, and they asked them what was more important in those commercial decisions they were making. Was it the business value, so the value to the business that they were working for, or was it the personal value, the value to them as an individual? And if you're thinking about it, Home or Economicus would go, "Well, I'm working for that business. The profitability of that business is is what should be guiding my decision making here. So the business value should be the critical thing." But what they found was that twice it was twice as important the personal value to that individual in terms of is this going to get promoted? Is this going to, you know, make me more popular with my colleagues, and though and so on? Those personal aspects were twice as important than the business value, in terms of what drove the commercial decision. So, the evidence is there that Homer. I like to say Homer works in the city as well as the nuclear power plant. You know, he's he's very much. You know, we don't. When we put on our work clothes and go to an office, or when we jump on a on a Teams call, you know, we don't suddenly become fundamentally different people. And all the evidence that we've had from behavioral science over the last 1500 years about how people behave outside of a business context that applies equally within the business world as well. All Kurt Nelson 17:39 right. So since Homer Simpson is running the business today with the productivity boost that we get from AI, and I can see Homer using AI, right? Is there any need for behavioral science, or is that just a thing of the past for businesses now? Because Homer will be running just using AI, and you know, having his little ticky butt ducks, you know, hitting the red buttons when now it's run by AI. There you go. Richard Chataway 18:06 Yeah. So it's really interesting. I think you know, and I know you've talked to this on the podcast before, and have had some great experts around this before. The evidence is is that you know, sure, you know, there are some fundamentals and some more routine, repetitive-based tasks that AI can do for people in a business, for Homer in that in that example. But but what that means is that you know the bits that AI can't do, the bits that require that require uniquely human traits like creativity and empathy, etc. And you know, I spend a lot of my career working customer experience, for example. And those we know those factors are critical to to great customer experiences. They become more integral to the job, and and they become you know to give one example, you know, in the world that that I've just been I've been working in most recently in my career, where a lot of the work was focused around contact centers, so people calling up with you know queries or wanting to make a purchase via the phone. You know, it used to be that 80%. If you worked in a contact center, 80% of your day was dealing with fairly routine, basic queries. You know, I want I'm changing my address. Where's my delivery? Those kind of things, and they were very low. You know, low cognitive tasks in terms of you know the skills and abilities and things required, and and relatively routine and and therefore not too taxing for the people working in that contact center, and 20% of your time might be on the the more complex queries, which are more require more empathy, more creativity, are more demanding both psychologically but also potentially physically as well, and. What's happened is there's just been this complete shift in the last few years, where because we've been able to automate a number of those routine queries, you know, people can get their delivery updates or whatever it might be through AI and other automated tools, chatbots, etc. That the day job of someone working the contact center has completely changed. So they're spending 80% of their day. So to give you an example, I was talking to a head of customer experience for a leading retailer here in the UK a couple of months ago, and he was saying, you know, when I every week I listen into some calls just to see how the teams are doing and performing and handling and the kind of queries we're getting, and he said it used to be when I'd listened into calls on my weekly hour of call listening. Most of them were those basic kind of queries about where's the delivery, where's you know this order wasn't what I ordered, you know etc. Can I get a replacement? And he said the last time I he jumped on some calls the day before. He said one of them was from a customer who said your delivery driver drove over my prize-winning roses in my front yard and didn't say sorry. What are you going to do about it? Now, that's a very high-risk interaction and one where you know if you get it wrong, you've lost a customer. But also potentially, if you could do handle it well, then potentially you can drive some customer loyalty from it as well. But he said that's what they're dealing with all day, and if you're someone working in a contact center, and suddenly your day job has gone to being being shouted at by angry customers, dealing with complex, you know, emotionally driven inquiries all day, we know that one that is more psychologically demanding, but also two, the skill sets required of people are very different for that. So the job has fundamentally changed. So, to your point, and to your question, I appreciate this is a speed round. That wasn't a very speedy answer, but Tim Houlihan 21:48 whatever. But yeah, Richard Chataway 21:51 but to your point, yeah, you know, those the the the the job has changed, and the job is changing for a lot of people because of what AI is bringing to the table, and it's democratizing to some extent in terms of those basic routine tasks and things like, you know, when we hire for jobs in things like contact centers, it might be about typing speed and literacy and things like that. It can level the playing field around that, but what it means is those those parts of the job that require what used to be called softer skills, the more you know, the the more psychologically demanding part of the job is becoming a more of the job in time terms, but b also more critical in those roles. And and what a lot of the work that I've been doing, my teams have been doing over the last few years, has been building up those skill sets using behavioral science principles for people. Kurt Nelson 22:36 And and I think that's a really good part that there's the behavioral side of things are becoming more important as opposed to less important to a certain degree. Given what you just said, so you wrote your book back in 2020, right? And so you were writing it in 2020 18, 2019, yeah, 2018, 2019, and you had a lot of components in there about AI, and obviously AI has done a massive change, even in that time. But you talked about it back then. What are some of the things that you're seeing, or that you've seen in how AI has shifted, and some of the behavioral behavioral aspects of that that companies are focusing in on? You talked a little bit about it and just that that last answer, but where has it shifted? Where did you predict it, and where did you kind of go? Oh, I kind of got that. Maybe that was a little different than I thought. Yeah, Richard Chataway 23:30 yeah. Well, yeah. It's interesting you say that because I was writing in 2018, 2019, and and you know I should say the book. I interviewed 25 experts from a variety of different fields, behavioral scientists, but also people working, you know, in in technology in particular, to ask them about, you know, the the use cases, applications, and some of the trends they were seeing, and the people in technology field in particular were all saying, "You've got to write something about AI. This thing is going to be transformative over the next few years." So I should say it wasn't any particular foresight on my part. It's credit to those people who advised me to do it. So you know, I feel very fortunate, really, in terms of that I was a little bit ahead the curve with that. But but yeah, when I've been looking back at those sections and and I've been doing some more recent writing, building on those hypotheses that I had, I think what's been gratifying, if if that's the right word, is that those hypotheses have largely been stayed true to some extent, or I would still stand by those hypotheses. Is a better way of putting it, I guess. And and but the technology has moved on hugely. You know, the one of the ways I like to explain this is to say, you know, yes, technology moves super fast as we're seeing, you know, over those few years, but evolution doesn't, you know, human brains and and people, you know, haven't fundamentally changed in the last six seven years, and therefore, you know, behavioral biases and our understanding of those is still relevant, but the context, as you as you mentioned earlier, Tim, you know, the context has has has sort of changed and. And and context is critical. So, for example, Netflix. You know, when we inter interact with Netflix, there is an algorithm and a and a narrow AI sitting behind that, which is the recommendation engine, which is telling us you like this show, so you might also like this other show, and that's hugely valuable as a user because there's so many 1000s and 1000s of movies and shows we can watch on Netflix that it's an impossibly hard choice, paradox of choice that we face when we go on there on the platform, and so and people value that, and it's 80% of the content that's watched on Netflix is as a result that algorithm. So one of the things I pointed out in the book was to say you're already being AI is already being used to shape choice architecture in a range of contexts, and that's just going to grow as we get more capabilities around the AI, and also we gather more data around user behavior. But the but the use case is now around how we interact with AI and its influence on behavior. I kind of I talk about them in in the more recent evidence base is is two as kind of an input and an output problem, if you want to look at it that way. So you've got the inputs in terms of the data we're using to fuel these tools, and we know that we've all had the experience, right? Of when we go onto ChatGPT or whichever our preferred platform is, and it hallucinates a wrong answer. Yes, yeah, and that's a kind of well-known problem, and one that we've all experienced. And you know, I often when I talk about this, I say, look, you know, hallucination is is a bit of a misnomer for that because it's an error, basically. It's wrong. It's wrong. You know, if I if I look out the window and say it's raining when it's not raining, that's just wrong. It's not a it's not a hallucination unless I've taken some mind expanding drugs or something like that. It's it's going to be that's just not true. But but and that's obviously a problem, and that's to do with you know the data quality and how how that's being used. But also what we see is is obviously every all data that humans touch contains traces of bias. Tim Houlihan 27:03 So, using this behavioral science lens, Richard, what are corporations missing when it comes to AI today? Richard Chataway 27:13 Yeah, so I think you know, from from that input perspective, you know, the the understanding of the biases that are inherent in that data, you know. I think is is one of the things that they're not they're not understanding. So, yeah, what behavioral science gives us is that lens, as you say. So, when I think about in some of the contexts in which I've been working, particularly in customer experience, you know, with a behavioral lens, we can understand why customers might be behaving in a way that doesn't necessarily make sense immediately, or you know, a lot of the work that I've done over the last few years has been for about digital adoption. So you know, in in broad terms, you have a a brand where a lot of your interactions with customers might still be through the telephone, and you've created websites and apps and digital products to to service those needs for people, which has a benefit to the business in terms of being cheaper, but also potentially a benefit to the customer because, for example, websites are available 24 hours a day, and call centers often aren't. So, so you know, there's a there's a win win scenario whereby customers use more of those tools, but they we know people are creatures of habits. We know people have biases that prevent them from using and accessing those tools. How can we get people into using those? And a lot of the work that me and my teams have done around this through a process and product we call cognition audits is is identifying the behavioral biases that sit behind that and why people are not accessing those tools, and then leveraging those in, for example, what we say to customers on the phone to get them to use those tools. So, one example, if it's if it's helpful, if it's useful, we did a project on for a bank where again they had created these websites and apps for customers to use. People were a lot of customers were not using them. What we identified when we did some call listening and analysis was that at the end of calls with customers, the agents would often finish the call by saying something like, "If you have any more problems, you can call us back. We're here 24 hours a day." So this was a call center that was open 24 hours a day, and the problem with that is it's obviously framing the next interaction for the customer. If you have any more problems, call us back. I'm expecting Tim Houlihan 29:27 another problem then at that point. Quite, I'm just well. Richard Chataway 29:29 Yes, you're expecting a problem, and also if you have a problem, that the best thing to do is to phone. Whereas we wanted customers to go to the website, and then only if they couldn't find what they needed on the website is to is to call. So we train and coach them to say at the end of calls, you can find the answers to most problems on our website. But if you don't get what you need there, you can call us back. We're here 24/7. And you know that is a you know a behavioral nudge. It's it's encouraging usage of the website. It was one of several nudges that we used. That over the next 90 days, we we measured the next channel of interaction that customers had with the brand, and 14% of customers had shifted to using their digital channels as a result of that, and a number of nudges we used. So, it was a very powerful framing device that we could use in that context. So, I guess to answer your question, Tim, there's lots of ways that this can be applied, and that's one example of in one of those touch points where you can apply this to achieve some of those those business benefits. Kurt Nelson 30:28 Richard, so talking about AI, and one of the things that we've seen, and you're talking about it from you know the customer side of things, and you know I've been looking at AI a lot and kind of getting into the research and with my clients and various different things about some of the internal components. But I think I want to stay on the the customer side because I'd love to get your insight on this. We've seen a lot of blowback in the United States. A lot of trust issues. You know, there have been well documented booing at commencement speeches for colleges when the commencement speaker gets up and starts talking about AI and the students are booing. I think there's a an actual concern about what that's doing for job opportunities, what it's doing for a number of other things. But I think there's a consumer side of that too, where we're being inundated with AI-driven ads and AI-driven, you know, you know, customer service responses, and it's like I just want to talk to a a real person, and I'm you're putting me through. I have to do all of these steps before I get there, and and I can't even call anybody anymore. There's no phone number here. What are you seeing? And again, from your perspective, behavioral science says something about that trust, and says something about that. You know, part of it, I think, is the how rapidly this has been changing, and we're asking people to change, but just your thoughts on that? Richard Chataway 32:04 Yeah, so it's a really interesting question. So I guess it's the it's the flip side of what I was saying a minute ago in terms of the inputs and the data and recognizing the biases in the data is then the output side of it. You know, as AI, as more and more of our interactions are go move from being human to human to human to AI, what is you know what is the impact of that? And particularly, and one of the ways that I talk about this is that you know we can we we can be cognizant of the biases that determine a human to human interaction, but there's a different set of biases that apply when we have a human to AI interaction, and as you've actually described there, Kurt, there's a lot of negative biases that people have, which which they will which creates friction, and which which which people will often, you know, you can have the scenario of people saying, "I want to talk to a human," "I want to talk to a human," you know, in in the kind of customer experience world, and that's becoming people's defaults in a number of contexts, and you know the way one of the ways I explain this when I'm doing keynotes, for example, for for some of the brands I've been working with recently, is you know when I'm delivering that keynote, you know people are responding to it based on their biases, you know about me and about the content, but if that same content were being delivered by an AI avatar, so for example, if on this podcast it was an AI avatar of me rather than me, even if it was word for word the same, people would respond to it differently because of the biases that govern those interactions. And we see some really interesting examples of that. So one study that that I think is really illustrative around to your point about trust, for example, was one that was conducted in China, where they were looking at you know whether the the difference that in a human to AI interaction versus human to human interaction impacts on people's phoenix reciprocity and also whether they were more likely to behave in a trustworthy way, so the way the scenario there were two scenarios. So people were recruited into the study and they were interacting with a with a chat interface, and they were told that they were either going to be speaking to a human or to an AI. So they were split into two groups: either talking to a human or to an AI, and in the scenario was was you were told that the human or the AI had to pre-select a number between one and 10, and you had to guess what that number was with no other information. So it was just a random guess between one and 10 as to what it was, and then afterwards you were told what the correct answer was, and then so there was the opportunity for people to lie about the accuracy of their guess. So, so what the answer was always eight. So, so whatever your guess was, the answer was eight. But if actually people are choosing a random number between one and 10, so you think the average guess would be somewhere around five, right? Because it's just totally random number picking, and. But when people were talking, were guessing what a human had picked, the average guess was six. So people lied a little bit about the accuracy of their guess. When it was, they were picking a number chosen by an AI agent. The average guess was 6.9. So people lied a little bit more simply because it was an AI. So guessing it. Does that make sense? And even though there's no skin in the game in this scenario, there's no gain to it. They just it's just about can you pick a random number that someone else has pre-selected. But what where it got really interesting was when there was some skin in the game introduced in terms of financial gain. So the second scenario was that you had bought some clothing items online, and you wanted to return them, and the only way to get your shipping fee back was to say that they were faulty, and the shipping fee was relatively low value, something like five or $10. Richard Chataway 35:52 But the reality was there was nothing wrong with the items; you just didn't like them, and you either had that interaction again, either with a human customer service agent, or with an AI agent, and what they found was when people are interacting with a human customer service agent, 12% of people lied, were willing to lie, basically commit low-level fraud to get their money back. When they're interacting with an AI agent, 62% of people lied to get their money back. So 50% more people were willing to lie because they were dealing with an AI than they were with a human, and if you think about the implications of this, obviously huge implications for retailers in terms of the amount of fraud and and and money they potentially lose. But if you think about it in financial services context, people dealing with banks and so on, if you're if you're moving those interactions purely to AI without thinking about those implications, you're exposing yourself to huge amount of risk in terms of fraud potentially. And the analogy I like to draw is is with, for example, in retail environments, the use now of self-service checkout facilities, where we've one one of the consequences of that is there's been an increase in shrinkage and and theft from those stores. As a result, it's very much I think the same, the same effect or lack of authority bias and and reciprocity when people see human faces. We know it triggers feelings of reciprocity and social norms, and and and you know removing the human in the loop in that scenario means that people are just you know the fudge factor around people's honesty just increases. So, yeah, it's it's that that's one example of I think you know I think what you're what you're suggesting there in terms of you know I talk about it as a governance issue. You know we need to think about the solutions and how they're being presented to humans because news newsflash your customers are still humans. We're not, you know, we're not we're not reached the scenario yet. Well, we're selling to AI when we're when we're talking about business, but that may come in the future. Who knows? But but but you know, your customers are still still human, and therefore they still have these biases that are fundamental to their behaviors, and but there's a different set of biases that apply when we're using AI for delivery. Kurt Nelson 38:07 I think that's one of the biggest concerns that I have about business leaders right now. I think that again, we talked about Homer Simpson versus Homo economicus and up front and that big thing, and we are acting like all of our employees, all of our consumers, everything are going to be homo economicus or more like these rational, and that we don't, we're not driven as humans by emotions and you know these these I hate the word rational, right? But it it that more economically like sound rational choices that hey, I am going to do this, and I have all this information. No, we respond based upon an emotional response, and we rationalize it later. And whether that be with our employees, and we're going. Oh, we'll we'll implement AI, and they will just adopt it and love it and be using it. And we're you know they'll believe everything we say about how it's taking all the mundane tasks away and freeing it up for you to be you know using your brain more and having more interactive sessions, and not worry about oh you're taking my job away, or I don't want to be your customer service reps, right? You can imagine, you know, if I was went from one to the other in that example, that's a much more stressful job now. You know, I don't have 80% of my ones where, oh yeah, what's your address? We'll get you. We'll we'll ship it out again. Oh, thank you, great. This is now. It's like you're running over my roses. What are you going to do? It's like, oh my god, this is much harder. Yeah, Richard Chataway 39:45 absolutely. Yeah, and and one of the no, 100%, and and one of the if it's side effects of that, and something that that a number of the leaders that I've been talking to in in recent months have reported is as a result of. Exactly what you're describing there, Kurt. That that they're having high rates of attrition and churn and burnout from their staff because the job has fundamentally changed in the way you've just described. And one of the, I guess, one of the positive aspects, if you want to call it that, around the work that me and my teams would be doing is because we're using behavioral science techniques to better equip them in those scenarios. So, for example, you know the work we've done has been about complaint handling and how you can ensure that people achieve a better resolution from their complaint and also feel more more satisfied with the complaint that they get. Which you know, in very simple terms, is often about turning someone who gets onto the phone in a very angry, frustrated, very system one mode, and getting them into a more of a system two rational mode, where they they're more willing to accept whatever the the compensation might be for a particular interaction. That has we had a we did a project with a with a financial services brand where you know we had a very successful outcome in terms of complaint resolution. So they reduced escalation of complaints. So basically, people saying, "Right, I want to escalate this. I want to talk to the manager. I want to someone else to deal with this." We reduced that by 38%. But what was really interesting was at the end of the project or the pilot project that we ran, the operations lead said to me, he said, "I don't have a problem with absenteeism anymore," and that wasn't the goal of the project. But it was because we'd given better capabilities to the teams, and they weren't, as you say, having a very stressful, difficult day where they feel like because people who work in customer service they they want to deliver better outcomes to customers. That's why you do the job, and anyone who's in a job who feels like they're doing a bad job, that's incredibly demotivating. So if you upskill and equip people to do this, it solves a lot of your operational challenges as well. Tim Houlihan 41:54 Hey, Grooves! Quick break from the conversation to talk about something we don't bring up enough on the show. Yeah, that's right. When we're not behind the mic, we're working with organizations to apply behavioral science in ways that actually move the needle for leaders, teams, and whole cultures. Kurt Nelson 42:11 So whether it's designing smarter incentives, boosting engagement, setting goals that actually stick, or helping teams navigate change, we bring real science to real workplace challenges, Tim Houlihan 42:22 and we don't just talk theory. Our approach blends research-backed insights with hands-on strategies that drive results. Now we've seen small behavioral shifts lead to big wins in Fortune 500 companies, and scrappy startups, and even in mission-driven nonprofits. Kurt Nelson 42:40 Yeah, and we bring the same curiosity, creativity, and care to our client work that we bring to every episode of the show. Tim Houlihan 42:47 Really, I I think people might want more than what we bring to the show. Yeah, Kurt Nelson 42:54 you you probably have a point there. You're probably right. Tim Houlihan 42:57 Okay, so we'll bring more care and creativity to our work with you and your teams than what we do on the show. Kurt Nelson 43:04 Yes, more care. So, so if you're ready to build stronger motivation, better team dynamics, and maybe even make your workplace a little more groovy, Tim Houlihan 43:13 yeah, reach out to us. Grab us on LinkedIn or Facebook, or just drop us a line. We'd love to help you and your team find your groove, and I love the way that you talked about that as a pilot program because that leaves me to segue into test tube behaviors, which is pretty central to the to the work to your book. And I'm interested for our listeners, like, what is sort of the the cheapest or easiest gateway into testing or piloting or running that test tube experiment? You know, without disrupting the entire organization. Do you have an example that you could you could give us? Yeah, that sort of like this little, this tiny little switch that could be thrown just to see well what would work. Richard Chataway 44:06 Yeah, so I think you know that as I say, one of the a lot of the work that I've done over the last 1015 years or so has been focused in in those contact center environments, and they are a great kind of sandbox environment for being able to test in the way you've just described, Tim, because you know what you have is you have a defined interaction, a telephone call, and you have a defined outcome from that as well, and you have the ability to look at the data around the outcomes of that, and and we've also got you know a lot of capabilities now around using things like voice analytics to be able to to you know break down that data to really granular level. So what that means is you can run fairly easily and cheaply experiments, whereby you know, in very simple terms, you take a group, a pilot group, which might only be a small number of people. It doesn't have to be a huge number, and and you get them. To you know, you you test a set of interventions from that group on the calls that they are dealing with. Obviously, you need to put various controls in in place to make sure it's representative sample. So, for example, you know, we always make sure in our pilots that we've got a group of high performers, mid level performers, and low performers. So we're not, you know, we're not just cherry picking the good people who who are very highly and different levels of experience as well, age, gender, all of the different things that might influence the outcomes. But then you can, you just get them, you know, for over a period of a few weeks, you get them to pilot the new interventions that we develop. So we'll train that group, we'll give them a set of new scripts and language to use, and then pilot it with them, and then look at the outcomes versus the rest of the contact center, and so, and then you know at the end of the pilot we've got some learnings. We will have iterated around a lot of the solutions as well, use their feedback to optimize the the approach, and that's a you know from an operational viewpoint, I can tell you that a lot of the operations leads that we work with in those environments that my teams have worked with, they really like working with us because, in contrast to a lot of other consultants who come in, we don't fundamentally tell them to change their ways of working. Do you know what I mean? Which, which, understandably, in a lot of context can generate some friction, and people can be worried about their jobs and worried. And and obviously, you know, because we're also giving them greater competency and skills in their jobs, that's generally appreciated as well. So you know, we we say don't you know don't change for for 90% of people, nothing changes. We take a pilot group and we give them a new way of working, which is fundamentally just you know, well, I don't want to underplay it, but it's there are there are tweaks rather than fundamental changes that deliver this outcome, and therefore, and we're not we're not trying to tell them we're not trying to tell them their business, if you know what I mean, right? And we bring in our expertise to do that, and that's so. To your point, you know, I think we there's a huge benefit to that, not only terms of the outcomes, but actually, it's not hugely disruptive to the business. Tim Houlihan 47:11 Well, and and the benefit of these tests is coming out with better outcomes. And in a really lovely shout out to Sam Tatum, our very dear and departed friend in Australia. I can see you've got evolutionary ideas right there behind you. If if you've not read Sam Tatum's book, I just want to encourage every listener to go check it out because it is fantastic. Absolutely. But the story that that you relate about Sam and KFC in Australia. Oh yes, you know Ogilvy developed some 90 some ideas around how to do one thing just just chips for $1. It was just really simple message. How can we maximize that? And of course, an agency comes up with a lot of ideas. There were 90 of them, but they tested eight, and then they discovered that just that little twist. Actually, I won't give away. You you you tell the story of what the what the twist was that actually got a much better response than any of the others. Richard Chataway 48:12 Yeah. So so yeah, there's a great story from Tam. And yes, Sam was sorry, and I'm glad you you've mentioned Sam because I I met Sam in Sydney, friend of mine, and obviously we worked together at Ogilvy as well. Who's sadly no longer with us, but he, yeah, he had this great work he did in in Australia, as you say, for for KFC about how to articulate this deal they had of chips or fries for $1, and and it was yeah yeah I think what's great about that story is one, it exemplifies that test and learn approach and the test you behaviors, which I, which I talk about in the book. But two, it just shows as well. I think sometimes people can, when you when you use the word science, people think that means it's going to be restrictive. Whereas, as as you say, Tim, they had over 100 different, I think it was or 90 something articulations of chips for $1 using different behavioral science principles. So behavioral science really is a you know one of the keys about science is you build hypotheses and then you test them to prove find what's right. And behavioral science just gives us a great framework for building those hypotheses. It doesn't it's not restrictive in that sense. It works hand in hand with creativity, and and so yeah, they had all these different articulations. They then tested them via mostly through Facebook. I think Facebook ads where they were able to say you know to test them amongst fans of KFC and fans of other fast food brands. And the one that was most successful in terms of engagement but also purchase was limited to four per customer, which is a yeah, which was actually just a terms and condition that they had on the original ad concept. But wasn't new, but it's pretty Tim Houlihan 49:50 no. But it was, but it was using Robert Cialdini's principles of influence in in yeah scarcity yeah in the headline, right? So. Became salient, Richard Chataway 50:01 yeah, absolutely, and it's a it's a great example because, again, you know, and I know Rory Sutherland, who wrote the foreword to my book, has been a guest on your podcast as well. Roy's been a sort of mentor and and and friend of mine for for many years, again from from my Ogilvy days, and um and you know he he talks about how behavioral science helps us with these counterintuitive solutions, and that is very much a counterintuitive solution. You know, why telling people the maximum amount they could buy? Why would that drive more purchase? But but because of scarcity, it's exactly what it does. Kurt Nelson 50:32 Yeah, and I love the counterintuitive part of behavioral science. So I think that's the one piece where you know, oftentimes it's like, oh, well, that's just common knowledge, which a lot of it is. But there are those moments where it's like, oh, that's not exactly like I would have thought it would have been, right? So yeah, yeah. And there's so many Richard Chataway 50:51 examples. Yeah. Kurt Nelson 50:53 Oh, there's so so many examples. You know, we talk about getting in your groove here on Behavioral Grooves and and you know groove can mean different things for different people. But from your perspective, Richard, what should business leaders be thinking about from a behavioral science perspective to help their employees or maybe even their customers get in their groove? What what do you think they need to be thinking about from a behavioral science perspective? Richard Chataway 51:20 I mean, I guess you know, in line with that, that kind of central hypothesis of my book and my work, which is about this willingness to test and learn. And you know, I've there's a quote from Daniel Kahneman that I use in the book, which where he was interviewed, and someone said, "If you had a magic wand, what would you get rid of?" And he said, "Overconfidence." You know, I think there's too many decisions that people make in the world in general, but particularly in business, where they go, well, we know what the right thing to do is here, and then just plow on with it because it's what they've done for the last 20 years, or it's what their competitors are doing, and so on. and And one of the values of, for example, counterintuitive solutions is it gives you competitive advantage because it's counterintuitive. It means no one else is doing it, and therefore you can you can drive that competitive advantage. And so, I think getting in that groove is about how you build that mindset into the organization and make it part of the culture of the organization. Being willing to experiment and test and learn, you know, it doesn't mean it has to be high risk. As in the examples I've just mentioned, you know, in a contact center environment, it's not a huge operational shift or change that you need to build this in to your ways of working, and that's true of so many areas of business. You know the KFC example we just talked about. You know that marketing test probably cost them a few $1,000, maybe. You know, but the value was absolutely huge to KFC. So you know that willingness to test and learn, to recognize that you're, you know, by doing that, you can find these big wins that can get you a massive competitive advantage and be hugely profitable for you. And and the kind of I talk in the book about you know things like psychological safety and the and the the principles around that that that encourage that kind of mindset, a willingness to innovate and experiment and challenge conventional wisdom. I think is is that that I would see that as a business that's in its groove when they're doing that every day and it's not questioned. Kurt Nelson 53:05 Yeah, I love it. Love that. Tim Houlihan 53:07 That's a terrific way of thinking about that stuff. Thank you, Richard. It is time in our conversation we get to turn to music because I know that you have been prepping and looking. You've got another hour, right? I love it. Tim would love it. Tim would love it. There you go. Oh man, a guest after my own heart. Did you know that you're our favorite guest ever, Richard? I just Richard Chataway 53:34 know what to say. That's the principles of influence, isn't it? Pretty easy to Kurt Nelson 53:38 guess what can trigger Tim to be hey, you're my favorite guest. Tim Houlihan 53:44 So you're from the UK. You know Lauren Laverne's work on her BBC radio program. We we have stolen this question, this desert island disc question, directly from her unabashedly because we love it. But here's the setup for you. You're on a desert island for a year. You have a listening device, but you can only take two artists on that listening device. Which two will you take? Richard Chataway 54:11 Well, I like the fact that you've chosen artists rather than individual songs because individual songs would be impossibly hard question. I think, yeah, and I think I definitely know one of them, and that would be the band Blur, if you know Blur. Who, yeah, UK bands who very much were kind of my first. Is that Tim Houlihan 54:30 B L U R Blur? Yes, yes, Richard Chataway 54:33 that's right. Yeah, yeah, like Tim Houlihan 54:34 okay, yes, Richard Chataway 54:35 like a Blur. Yeah, and who were very much my kind of first musical passion, enthusiasm, if you like, and they and because they've had their career has kind of lasted my music listening career, if you want to call it that. And I've seen them multiple times in the UK and in Australia as well. And they produce a lot of albums. I think there would be enough, and there'd be enough variety in that back catalog to keep me going over a year. I think so. They. Definitely be my choice, just because, and they are my favorite band, probably of all time. I do have a kind of slight personal connection there as well, in that I, the eagle-eyed amongst people watching this on YouTube, might spot a football shirt behind me, as I said, for my team, Ipswich Town. They, the band, were formed in Colchester, which is a town about 15 miles from Ipswich, so they're from sort of my my part of the world. Want to call it that. Even though the most famous Ipswich fan is Ed Sheeran, who very nice guy, but music's not not his music is not not my taste. But did you go to school with Ed? Did Tim Houlihan 55:35 you have do you have personal? No, oh, he's much Richard Chataway 55:37 younger than me. But yeah, he's but he did. He again grew up very close to where I grew up, actually. But yeah, no, I say not my taste. His music's good, but not yeah, you know, not not your. I'm a different different generation. But he, but yeah, but Blur probably would be my. So I Kurt Nelson 55:57 was I was introduced to Blur with Song Two, which is the one huge in the U.S. Is it probably their biggest hit globally? Richard Chataway 56:05 Yes, Kurt Nelson 56:05 yeah. Tim Houlihan 56:06 So, Richard, what is your number two artist that you're going to take with you on the desert island? Richard Chataway 56:12 So, yeah. So, I was really scratching my head trying to think of who the the second artist would be, but and I get this is, I guess, a behavioral bias in terms of mental availability because I've been listening to them a lot over the last couple of weeks, and I saw them perform at the weekend. Who are a Welsh band called the Super Furry Animals? Super Tim Houlihan 56:32 Furry Animals. Okay, yeah. So, Richard Chaddaway, thank you so much for being a guest today on Behavioral Grooves. It's really been a pleasure. Richard Chataway 56:41 Likewise, thanks very much for having me. Kurt Nelson 56:51 Welcome to our grooving session, where Tim and I share ideas on what we learned from our discussion with Richard. Have a free-flowing conversation, and groove on whatever else comes into are still human, not AI generated brains. Tim Houlihan 57:05 Yes, yeah, we are still still human. At least, Kurt Nelson 57:09 at least I think you are. I mean, you might be a replicant. You might be, you know, I don't know, Tim. You a Tim Houlihan 57:17 deep fake of me. Kurt Nelson 57:18 Deep fake of you. I know it's like the the world is like on. We need more of Tim. I need to get Tim so we do make a deep fake of you. And then I'm I don't know the difference. I'm dealing with you just like yeah, Kurt Nelson 57:33 like you're the real Tim, but you're not. Maybe I'm not the real Kurt. I don't know. Oh, Tim Houlihan 57:39 that's wild. Are you a deep fake of you? Kurt Nelson 57:43 All right, not to not to not to get too deep into this, but the Blade Runner. Do you remember that movie? Right, I do. Help me understand. I I hope I'm interpreting this right, but part of the story of Blade Runner is that the they don't know that they're not human. The Tim Houlihan 58:07 mutants don't know. That's right. Kurt Nelson 58:08 Yeah, then that's mutants. The machine. The machines. Tim Houlihan 58:12 Machines. Sorry. Kurt Nelson 58:14 And I think that's a that's a fascinating thing. Like if you thought you were like, what if you weren't? What if this is not real? What if you are some copy of you, some deep fake, but still have those feelings and don't know that you're a deep fake? I mean, and it Tim Houlihan 58:36 also begs a question of if you really believe something to be the truth, even though it's it's not the truth. It's not correct. Are you lying when you say that? Kurt Nelson 58:48 Oh, that's a whole that's a whole conversation that we could just take a deep deep dive on. All right, Tim Houlihan 58:57 let me follow the lying thing though with just this this question about the the story that Richard brought up about the customers that when they're talking to a human were less likely to lie compared to when they were talking to the AI bot. Yeah, and I think that the the insight that you brought up in the introduction is really key, right? Human nature hasn't left the conversation. You could take human out of it, but the human nature hasn't gone, right? If we if if we disappear humans because AI is doing all the easy work, then we're still going to be in a world of hurt because the human on the other end is still going to be a human. They're still going to act like humans. They're still going to default to human biases and and tendencies. Kurt Nelson 59:49 Right. We have this idea. So the AI is interacting with a human, and. That interaction, because one side is human, is still having all of those the human nature component within that, and part of that is that in this lying piece, right? There's this element of it goes back to the the the cheating kind of research, right? There was Nina Mazar, Amir, and Arielli when they did that that idea that we cheat. Most of us cheat a little bit, Tim Houlihan 1:00:40 yeah. Most, but only, Kurt Nelson 1:00:43 but only as much. While we're still feeling like we're good, we can we can justify it away. And if I'm lying, that's like cheating. And if I'm lying to another human, there's something that feels wrong. Like I'm, like I'm, I'm cheating you. I'm, I'm cheating you out of this little bit. But if it's to a bot, it's not human. It doesn't feel as bad, at least at some some deeper level as as as a human. Tim Houlihan 1:01:15 It might be the difference, like in retail stores where research has been done that mannequins were originally brought in just to show the you know to show this is this is how you could put clothes on. This is how the clothes would look. This is how they look. But then they thought, oh, actually having mannequins might actually reduce theft. And it turns out that that's not the case. Mannequins don't reduce theft, but it might be because they actually don't look like humans. Whereas when we talked to Tara Reid in episode 167 about the babies in the burrow, modeling where they painted actual children on the the the doors of the shops, Kurt Nelson 1:01:54 babies with their big fat faces. Yeah, Tim Houlihan 1:01:56 and they were real baby. They were actually the babies of the shop owners, that actually did have a positive effect on reducing violence and and you know trouble in the neighborhood. So this whole idea, you know, so it does matter if it if we feel like oh there's something really human here. Kurt Nelson 1:02:15 The the eyes watching eyes research too, where they did the the paying for coffee. Like you had to put money in for coffee voluntary. Voluntary. It's like, oh, here's the coffee pot. Make sure you put in 50 cents for your cup of coffee. But it was on the honor system, and they got a lot more when they put pictures of human eyes above the coffee pot, so that like, yeah, hey, you know, and and there's a weird part about that because you kind of go, it's like Big Brother watching you, but the part is that it's a human part, and it makes you self reflect. It makes you think about, is this who I want to Tim Houlihan 1:03:00 be, and that is an important part of this conversation, and I think it's part of what Richard is talking about here. and And it doesn't necessarily happen when you're dealing with a AI agent versus a real human. Self checkout are notoriously worse at at theft than you know than when you're checking out in any kind of retail situation with a cashier or a clerk of some kind. 65% higher, 65% higher, and some of that might be because of mistakes and lack of familiarity. Because Kurt Nelson 1:03:38 I can't I can't use that damn scanner, and I, I would think that it actually just takes mine because I like scan it three times and now I have three of those damn things, so I'm overcharged on that. So I've Tim Houlihan 1:03:51 I've walked away paying multiple times for a tube of toothpaste. But I thought when when I was doing a little research on that topic, I found that that Gen Z shoppers are actually 37% more likely to steal from a self-checkout than the average consumer, and millennials are almost 52% more likely. What is that crazy? So Kurt Nelson 1:04:16 those damn kids. There you go. Tim Houlihan 1:04:18 All right. Okay. What What else do you have to to say about this? Kurt Nelson 1:04:24 So, I think one of the most important pieces that Richard brought up, and this is the work that we've talked about before, but in a different manner, is how AI changes the job. This idea that Richard talked about with the customer service piece that you're switching that 80% 2080 20 rule of 80% of this is just normal everyday. Hey, I need to you know. Can you track my package? Or hey, it got damaged in shipping. Can how do I return this? You know all of those types of questions that you would get that are relatively easy, and you can answer that to if AI takes that away, then my role changes, and that is a huge component that AI is changing our jobs. Not always, and we don't think about it in these ways. We we know what it's doing. It's like, oh, you're getting to do this, but there's an emotional component to that. There's the human nature component to that. Tim Houlihan 1:05:37 Yeah, if if AI is is doing the easy calls, then the human stuff is all emotional labor. It's high emotional, and that's going to lead to higher burnout, you know, higher turnover. And I think that this is this is just something that we need to pay attention to as as we as we go through this, as we you know envelop this this AI into our world. Do we want AI to be doing the easy work, or can we get AI handling more difficult problems to actually make it easier for and and better for the humans to do the human stuff? Kurt Nelson 1:06:16 Well, it's about how do we design the Interaction that we have with AI, how we design the work that we're doing as a result of the work being shifted. Again, you know, we've talked about like the connections and the lack of you know some of the interpersonal connections that disappear when AI comes into the thing. We talk about some of the trust issues with different things, and Richard talks about this with this emotional labor part. And I love the component of saying, "All right, so now that you're dealing with these angry people, you ran over my rose garden. I can't do the cake, cakey thing. You know, you ran over my roses, right? That you have to shift how you work, and and I like that moving those angry callers from system one to system two, and that pilot that he talked about. I thought that that was very interesting, not just because of like redesigning how you do that work, but the impact that that had on the people that it actually did like it made their their job more meaningful to a certain degree, right? That didn't it decrease absenteeism, right? Is that that's Tim Houlihan 1:07:36 right? It it did right. There's there's there's positive effects that can come from that. One of my best customer service experiences is with Sonos, the the audio company. So they have they have wireless audio, and after failing at getting it set up in my in my house after the five times that I've moved in the last four years, I was having trouble on one of these occasions. I called their customer service, and I was on the phone for 90 minutes solving the problem because the customer service person wouldn't let me off the call until it was fully functional. This whole idea of oh, you know, if you have any more more troubles, you know, give us a call back. You know that is the wrong frame. They they sat with me, they walked through it, and it took a long time. But it was satisfying for me and satisfying for the customer service person because they ended the call going, I know that I helped them fix the problem. Their system is up and running, and that's good for everybody. Kurt Nelson 1:08:43 Yeah, and I think that's a that's a really important piece. And Richard talks about piloting designs and doing all of that, and I think that's a really important aspect of that. I'm really though when we think about this, right? AI doesn't remove the human part within a job. Tim Houlihan 1:09:06 That's right. Kurt Nelson 1:09:07 Right. It either with customers or internally with other employees or with my manager, it shifts them and it concentrates them. But customers are still human. Your peers are still human, right? Tim Houlihan 1:09:22 That's right. Kurt Nelson 1:09:23 And I think that's interesting because again, people don't lie to Tim Houlihan 1:09:32 other the the Kurt Nelson 1:09:33 AI agents because they're bad people. It's the structural part of this. It's a it's it's kind of like my lying to a non-human doesn't impact anybody. It doesn't you know if I'm lying to a human that that's a a I'm I'm hurting that person. I'm I'm I'm making you know it's it's a bad thing right? But a bot is a bot. It's an AI. I. It doesn't have feelings. It doesn't get hurt, right? Tim Houlihan 1:10:03 That's it. That's it. And it's easy to it's easy to differentiate and distance ourselves from that. Kurt, anything else before we close? Kurt Nelson 1:10:12 Let's close. Tim Houlihan 1:10:14 So, if you're not subscribing to our Substack, please do so because you get great ideas from behind each episode and in addition to each episode, so it's not just a rehash of what we what we talk about in the episode. We also want to encourage you to join the Behavioral Grooves community page on Facebook because there's great content posted almost every day, great exchanges, great opportunities to get to know other people through cool things that they have to say, and there's the really lovely thing about that is that I don't remember anyone just getting on and being a bot. You know, I don't know if we've had any stupid bots on the behavior group's community page. I think it's actually real people. It is Kurt Nelson 1:10:58 real people, but Tim Houlihan 1:11:00 yeah, Kurt Nelson 1:11:00 you know, and one of the nice things too is that while we pose questions, you know, if you're a community member, you can pose questions. So you could go out there, you could pose a question of that's Speaker 1 1:11:12 right. Kurt Nelson 1:11:12 Would you be more honest with a person or a chat bot? Be honest about that, right? You could put that out as a group, you know, question, and we would have a great conversation in going back and forth on that, and it wouldn't be with bots. It Tim Houlihan 1:11:28 would not. Also, if you're listening to this, if you're watching on YouTube or listening on Apple or Spotify or any of the 150 other platforms we're on, please just leave us a a short review or just a a quick rating. Just give us some stars. Just the the it really feeds the algorithms in a positive way that helps other people discover Behavioral Grooves, Kurt Nelson 1:11:54 and it and it feeds our ego, which is the more important thing here. And we haven't had a review in a long time, at least not one that I've seen. We need, I mean, we had a whole bunch of reviews, and now it's like they just trickle in. And it's I don't know, everybody that listens has already left one, or but if you haven't, get on the damn bandwagon, people. Here you go. So, Tim Houlihan 1:12:17 so this week, change consider changing how you close a customer call or run a small pilot before you actually roll out a big, you know, initiative, or maybe keep a human face somewhere in your AI experience so that your customers know that there's still people on this end. And we hope that you use one of those ideas this week to go out and find your groove. Transcribed by https://otter.ai